Orchestrate

The payment on the wrong customer

Break-fix drill · Finance · about 6 minutes · starts after stage 11 of 11, "Pay and close the month", and the Collect the cash chapter up to "Import the bank's statement" in *The bank statement* (Brennock's BWU-PO-5760 and Hallam's HFS-PO-7951 billed, each one ES-200, 4,324.38 and 3,777.19 open)

What the user reports

Monday morning at Rockford. On Friday a cheque for 3,777.19 came from HFS HOLDINGS LLC with "PAYMENT 7951" on the remittance, and the accountant keyed it on Incoming payments between two Brennock entries. Today Brennock's transfer of 4,324.38 for BWU-PO-5760 arrives and won't post, and Hallam's invoice for HFS-PO-7951 still shows as open, a week before the next dunning run.

The error: Payment refused on Incoming payments: Brennock's 4,324.38 for its invoice is "more than the customer's open items (547.19)", although Brennock has paid nothing on it.

What you'll do

  1. See the problem as the accounts receivable accountant: On Incoming payments, post 4,324.38 from Brennock 10000001 in CP10, naming the invoice for BWU-PO-5760.
  2. Find the cause: Brennock has paid nothing on this invoice, yet only 547.19 is open on it. What happened?
  3. Fix it as the accounts receivable accountant.
  4. Prove it: run the step that failed again.

Start the drill

The drill runs in the lab on its own prepared copy of the fictional Calder Pumpworks, saved in this browser apart from your company. All codes and values are fictional course labels.

Answer and explanation (open after the drill)

The fix: Yesterday's 3,777.19 from Hallam's parent was posted against Brennock's invoice, so Brennock's item shows paid and Hallam's still shows open.

Open is what the invoice was minus what was posted against it. Payments posted on Incoming payments shows the 3,777.19 under Brennock's name against Brennock's invoice, the same amount as Hallam's open invoice for 7951. The money is real and in the bank; it sits on the wrong customer. No bill was doubled, nothing was written off and Brennock's order has no discount terms.

Why it broke

A payment was keyed to the customer left selected from the entry before. The amount was smaller than Brennock's invoice, so nothing refused it: a payment of less than an invoice leaves the rest open, and the item looked part-paid. The money landed in the bank and on the wrong account at once.

How teams prevent it

Post receipts from the bank's statement, where the text names the order or invoice and the proposal names the customer, and key by hand only what the statement can't carry. A payment whose amount matches another customer's open invoice exactly is worth a second look before it posts.

Across teams

Accounts receivable keyed it, Brennock's accounts payable sees a refusal it can't explain, Hallam may get a dunning letter for an invoice its parent paid, and the credit manager reads Hallam's exposure as higher than it is.

Where AI fits

Predict and assist: a model that knows each customer's usual payers and references can flag a payment whose amount equals another customer's open invoice before it posts. The reversal itself stays with a person, with a reason.

Learn more: Order to cash end to end

All drills · Back to the lab

Sign in to track your progress

We'll email you a one-time sign-in link. No password needed.

or

Tell us a little about you

Optional, every field. It helps us pitch answers to your questions at the right level and decide which topics to write next. It is never shown publicly, and you can change or clear it anytime from the account menu.

SAP areas you work in