The forklift billed to the wrong customer
What the user reports
Month-end at Calder, 2026-12-21. Harwick Lift Truck Sales agreed to buy idle forklift FL-3 (asset 30000025) for 12,500.00 USD, its reference HLT-PO-2291. This morning the fixed asset accountant retired the forklift on Asset retirements: she typed "Ha" in the buyer field and took the first name it offered. At noon Harwick's driver collects the forklift and hands over the payment.
The error: Accounts receivable can't post Harwick's 12,500.00 USD: customer 10000045 has no open items in CP10. The billing document for the forklift, with Harwick's reference on it, is open on Hallam Fluid Systems (10000002), a distributor of Calder's pumps, and counts against Hallam's credit limit.
What you'll do
- See the problem as the accounts receivable accountant: On Incoming payments, post 12,500.00 USD from 10000045 Harwick Lift Truck Sales Inc., naming the billing document of the forklift's sale.
- Find the cause: The forklift is off the books and the loss of 1,600.00 is right. Why can't Harwick's payment be posted?
- Fix it as the fixed asset accountant.
- Prove it: run the step that failed again.
The drill runs in the lab on its own prepared copy of the fictional Calder Pumpworks, saved in this browser apart from your company. All codes and values are fictional course labels.
Answer and explanation (open after the drill)
The fix: The sale was retired to Hallam (10000002): the receivable and the billing document sit on the customer chosen at retirement, so Harwick has nothing open to pay.
The retirement bills the buyer it is given: here Hallam, with Harwick's reference on the bill. Harwick exists as a customer in CP10 (the chapter created it), and asset sales are paid on Incoming payments like any invoice; there is just nothing open on Harwick. The asset values are right, which is why nothing looked wrong until the money came.
Why it broke
The buyer was picked from a list by the first letters of its name, and the posting checked only that the buyer is a customer with data in the company code. The asset side was right, so nothing looked wrong until a payment came that had nothing to clear.
How teams prevent it
Pick a buyer by number, from the signed sale agreement, and read the name back before posting. A sale to a customer that has never bought from Calder (Harwick) against one that buys pumps every month (Hallam) is worth a second look; so is a buyer's reference that doesn't follow the customer's own numbering.
Across teams
The fixed asset accountant posted it; accounts receivable couldn't apply Harwick's money; once overdue, Hallam would have been dunned for a forklift it never bought, and the 12,500.00 counts against Hallam's credit limit, where it can block its next pump order; the asset itself was right, so only the receivable side had to be undone.
Where AI fits
Assist, at the point of entry: a check that compares the buyer with the sale agreement (name, reference format, whether the customer has ever bought anything but pumps) can flag the pick before it posts. Matching an unapplied payment to the right open item is a good model task too, but here no open item fits: the fix is the accountant's reversal, not a payment moved to Hallam's bill.
Learn more: Record to report, end to end