Orchestrate

The bench that failed its sign-off

Break-fix drill · Production · about 7 minutes · starts after stage 11 of 11, "Pay and close the month", and the Maintenance chapter up to "Sign the bench back" in "Work the overhaul" (the test bench TB-1's annual overhaul from MP-TB-12M worked from 13 to 15 April 2027, every operation confirmed except the inspection step 0050)

What the user reports

Thursday 15 April 2027, the last day of the test bench's overhaul. At the final pressure test the relief valve weeps at 1.5 times working pressure, and the technician records the inspection as failed. Production's first pumps are due on the bench on Friday morning, so the production supervisor asks the maintenance planner to close the order and hand the bench back. Completing the order is refused.

The error: Completion refused on the overhaul: inspection 0050 failed on 2027-04-15: the work isn't signed off. Add the rework before it, then inspect again.

What you'll do

  1. See the problem as the maintenance planner: On Maintenance orders, complete the overhaul (called from MP-TB-12M) on 2027-04-15 with cause WEAR and Annual overhaul done: impeller worn thin and replaced, seals and valves renewed, relief valve re-seated after a failed first test, bench recalibrated.
  2. Find the cause: Every operation has its hours, and production needs the bench tomorrow. What stands between the planner and a completed order?
  3. Fix it as the maintenance planner.
  4. Prove it: run the step that failed again.

Start the drill

The drill runs in the lab on its own prepared copy of the fictional Calder Pumpworks, saved in this browser apart from your company. All codes and values are fictional course labels.

Answer and explanation (open after the drill)

The fix: The failed test left the inspection open: add the valve's rework before 0050 with the failure as its reason, confirm it, and test again; only a passed inspection signs the bench back.

The inspection step is the record that hands the machine back. A failed result means the work isn't good yet, so the order waits for the rework and a second test. Recording a pass that didn't happen hands production a bench whose relief valve weeps at test pressure. A separate order doesn't change the open step on this one, and nothing settles before the order is complete.

Why it broke

Nothing was misconfigured: the inspection did its job. The failed test posted its hour and left 0050 open on purpose, because the bench isn't fit to hand back. The pressure to close came from production's schedule, and the only honest way through is the rework and a second test.

How teams prevent it

Plan the inspection as a hold point with time for one rework inside the stop (the package had 19 of 24 hours, so 1.5 more still fits), and tell production the moment a test fails, with the new hand-back time. A failed test is a finding: it belongs in the order with its reason, where next year's package sees it.

Across teams

The technician tests and records the result, the planner adds the rework and owns the stop, production waits for its bench, and quality relies on the bench's calibration for every pump it signs off. A pass recorded to save a day would put every test on that bench in doubt.

Where AI fits

A model can read the failed test's note and draft the rework operation and its reason, citing earlier relief-valve work on the bench, for the planner to approve. Signing the bench back stays with the technician who ran the test; no rule or model records a pass.

Learn more: Maintain to settle: plant maintenance and assets

All drills · Back to the lab

Sign in to track your progress

We'll email you a one-time sign-in link. No password needed.

or

Tell us a little about you

Optional, every field. It helps us pitch answers to your questions at the right level and decide which topics to write next. It is never shown publicly, and you can change or clear it anytime from the account menu.

SAP areas you work in