Two impellers at H20
What the user reports
Monday 21 December at Rockford. Design released revision B of EP-900's engineering bill last week: a larger impeller CP-IMP901 at position H20 from change record EC-1002, 4 January. Late on Friday the production engineer carried it onto the plant's bill: the CP-IMP900 line ends with EC-1002, and a CP-IMP901 line starts with it at H20, operation 0010. This morning design asks why Rockford still hasn't accepted revision B.
The error: Acceptance of revision B refused on Engineering change decisions: the manufacturing bill in CP11 doesn't carry revision B yet on 2027-01-04, position H20 still out of step.
What you'll do
- See the problem as the production engineer: On Engineering change decisions, record EP-900, plant CP11, revision B: decision Accepted.
- Find the cause: Both lines carry EC-1002, and the CP-IMP901 line names position H20 and operation 0010. Engineering and manufacturing bills still shows H20 out of step on 4 January. Why?
- Fix it as the production engineer.
- Prove it: run the step that failed again.
The drill runs in the lab on its own prepared copy of the fictional Calder Pumpworks, saved in this browser apart from your company. All codes and values are fictional course labels.
Answer and explanation (open after the drill)
The fix: The CP-IMP901 line says 2 per pump; position H20 on the engineering bill says 1.
The comparison traces each engineering position to the manufacturing line that names it on the change record's date, and checks the part and the quantity. On 4 January H20 finds the CP-IMP901 line, the right part, but 2 per pump against design's 1: Quantity differs. Two lines may carry one position when one ends with the change record the other starts with, which is what keeps the old line as the record of earlier pumps.
Why it broke
Production carried the change across with the right part, dates and position, and the wrong quantity. Had the acceptance gone through, every EP-900 started from 4 January would have taken two CP-IMP901: MRP would have bought two from Tamsfield for each pump, at 1,310.00 each, and the cost estimate would have carried both. The comparison exists to catch exactly this before production says yes.
How teams prevent it
Production accepts a revision only when the comparison is clean on the change record's date, and the lab enforces it. A second pair of eyes on the comparison (design reads it too) catches what the person keying the lines doesn't see. Where the plant bill really does need a different quantity (scrap allowance, a part cut in two), the reason belongs in writing for design.
Across teams
Design owns the engineering bill and waits for an answer; the production engineer owns the plant's bill and the acceptance; the planner and the buyer would have ordered from the wrong quantity; the controller would have costed it. The handover between design and production is where a typo becomes a purchase order.
Where AI fits
Comparing two bills position by position is plain automation, and the lab already does it. A model is useful one step earlier: proposing the manufacturing lines from a released revision (part, quantity, position, operation) for the production engineer to review, with every proposed line traced to its position. The acceptance stays a person's decision, because it commits the plant to a date.
Learn more: Master data that every module depends on