Orchestrate

Two impellers in every pump

Break-fix drill · Production · about 6 minutes · starts after stage 11 of 11, "Pay and close the month", and the Product lifecycle chapter up to "Start the new impeller with the change" in *Engineering change* (change record EC-1001, the redesigned impeller CP-IMP210 planned, priced and sourced, the old impeller's line ending with the change)

What the user reports

Monday 21 December at Rockford. On Friday the product engineer put the impeller redesign on ES-200's bill of material: the old impeller CP-IMP200 ends with change record EC-1001, valid from 1 February, and the redesigned CP-IMP210 was added for it. This morning the production supervisor created an order for four ES-200 starting today; the impellers, motors and seal kits for them were bought last week.

The error: Release of the order for four ES-200 refused: missing parts, CP-IMP210 (need 4, available 0). Nobody has bought the redesigned impeller, and it isn't due until February.

What you'll do

  1. See the problem as the production supervisor: On Production orders, release the order for 4 ES-200 starting today. (If the order says its bill of material has changed since it was created, Read bill of material again first.)
  2. Find the cause: EC-1001 isn't valid until 1 February, so a pump started today should take only CP-IMP200. Why does today's order want CP-IMP210 as well?
  3. Fix it as the production engineer.
  4. Prove it: run the step that failed again.

Start the drill

The drill runs in the lab on its own prepared copy of the fictional Calder Pumpworks, saved in this browser apart from your company. All codes and values are fictional course labels.

Answer and explanation (open after the drill)

The fix: The CP-IMP210 line has no Valid from, so it counts from the start: today's bill has both impellers.

A bill of material line is valid on a date when the change record that starts it has taken effect and the one that ends it hasn't. The old line ends with EC-1001, so it stops on 1 February as it should. The new line starts with nothing, which means "valid from the start": today ES-200's bill has two impellers per pump, and an order copies the bill valid on its start date. Changes and effectivity shows CP-IMP210 needed before its change date.

Why it broke

A change is two edits that belong together: the old line ends on the date and the new line starts on the same date. Only half of it carried the change record. A line without Valid from is valid from the start, so from Friday until 1 February ES-200's bill said two impellers per pump. Every order created in that time copied both, and MRP would have planned CP-IMP210 for January's pumps, weeks before Tamsfield can deliver it.

How teams prevent it

Both lines of a change are entered under the change record together, and the change is checked on Changes and effectivity before anyone plans from it: the new part should first be needed on the change date, not before. A bill with two parts at the same place in the product (two impellers in one pump) is worth a check of its own.

Across teams

The product engineer changed the bill, the production supervisor created the order from it, the planner's next run would have asked purchasing for a part Tamsfield can't deliver in time, and the controller would have costed every pump with two impellers. Order release is where it surfaced, because that is where the parts are counted.

Where AI fits

Checking that every line a change record ends has a line that starts on the same date is plain automation. A model can help with the harder version: reading a change's description and the lines entered under it, and flagging when they don't match (the description says replace, the lines add). The engineer still decides the dates.

Learn more: Master data that every module depends on

All drills · Back to the lab

Sign in to track your progress

We'll email you a one-time sign-in link. No password needed.

or

Tell us a little about you

Optional, every field. It helps us pitch answers to your questions at the right level and decide which topics to write next. It is never shown publicly, and you can change or clear it anytime from the account menu.

SAP areas you work in